Co-ownership · Ontario

They won’t sell, and they won’t buy you out.

A brother, a sister, an ex-partner, a friend you bought with in a better year. Your name is on it, your money is in it, and you cannot get either of them out without their signature. Or so it looks from here.

A co-owner who will not move

Tell me the situation. I approach them neutrally, and never without your go-ahead.

Private, and nothing is sent to anyone else without your go-ahead. Prefer to talk first? Call or text (365) 645-7332.

Thank you. Your inquiry is in.

I reply personally, and in confidence, within one business day. If it is time-sensitive, call (365) 645-7332.

The part most people do not know

Under section 2 of Ontario’s Partition Act, a co-owner — joint tenant or tenant in common — has a prima facie right to compel partition or sale, and the other co-owners have a corresponding obligation to permit it. It is not absolute. A court keeps a discretion and can refuse where the person asking is acting maliciously, vexatiously or oppressively, and it will consider anyone living there.

The practical effect is that the person refusing usually cannot simply refuse forever. Which means the real question is not whether it gets resolved. It is on whose terms, and how much of the value survives the process.

Get your own lawyer to tell you how that applies to your situation. It will apply differently depending on the facts.

What it is actually about

Almost never the price. Underneath, in rough order of how often it comes up:

None of that is in a statement of claim, and none of it gets resolved by one. But it is usually what is actually holding the thing up.

The two roads

An application

Twelve to twenty months, contested.

Legal costs on both sides, out of the same pot — it is your equity either way.

You keep paying half of everything and receive nothing while it runs.

A court-ordered sale is not a well-prepared listing. It is rarely the number either of you had in mind.

And you will not be speaking afterward.

A mediated resolution

Weeks, not years.

Staged buyout, a listing trial at an agreed price with a pre-agreed reduction schedule, an appraisal collar where you cannot agree on value, or a clean sale with the accounting sorted properly.

The occupancy question, the contributions question and the mortgage release all handled in the same conversation instead of three separate fights.

One fixed fee, split. Private.

The thing worth doing before anything else

The number nobody has run

What is the property actually worth today, what would a court-ordered sale net against a properly prepared one, and what does eighteen months of carrying it cost the two of you between you?

Most co-ownership fights are conducted entirely without that arithmetic. It is frequently the thing that ends them, because both people discover they are arguing over less than the fight will cost.

You do not have to raise it with them.

Tell me the situation. If it is suitable, I approach them myself — neutrally, not as your representative, and never without your go-ahead first.

Start privately →

Or call or text (365) 645-7332. Nothing is sent to anyone else without your go-ahead.