Real Estate Dispute Resolution · Ontario

The goal isn’t to win the argument. It’s to solve the problem.

One thing, done properly: disputes with real estate at the centre of them. Whoever is on the other side — a buyer who didn’t close, a co-owner, a business partner, a sibling, a former spouse. Looking past the legal positions to what actually needs resolving: the money, the timing, the relationships, and what happens next.

Close to ten years practising real estate law in Ontario, and a licensed salesperson today. I know where deals actually break, what each step costs, and how long it really takes. I act for neither side, and I never take a listing out of a matter I mediate.

Two roads out of a dispute

One takes years. The other takes weeks.

In court
With Resolve
Time
1–2 years
A few weeks
Cost
unpredictableTens of thousands per side, before anyone wins
known up frontOne fixed fee, split between the parties
Privacy
A public court record, open to anyone
Private. Nothing is filed, nothing is searchable
Who decides
A judge you have never met
You do. Nothing is imposed on either side
The end
A ruling one side can appeal
An agreement you both signed
“Discourage litigation. Persuade your neighbors to compromise whenever you can. The nominal winner is often a real loser — in fees, expenses, and waste of time.”
Abraham Lincoln · Notes for a Law Lecture, c. 1850
Before you litigate

Even a win is rarely the win you pictured.

Winning gets you a judgment, and a judgment is not money. Collecting it is a second job: you go back to court to make them disclose what they own, then register against property or garnish a bank account, and none of it works if there is nothing there. Bankruptcy ends most of it outright. A judge can also see your slam-dunk very differently. Litigation is an expensive, drawn-out bet on being proven right — and it usually ends in a settlement anyway. Mediation trades the gamble for an outcome you actually control.

The difference

There is a solution inside almost every dispute. The work is finding it — calmly, and clearly.

I’m not here to be your litigator, and I won’t pretend to predict how a court would rule. What I bring is having seen that road from the inside. I know how slow, costly, and draining it is, and that it almost always ends in a settlement anyway. Resolving it directly gets you there at the start.

And a dispute is rarely only a legal question. Beneath it there is money, a business reality, a relationship, and two sides each certain they are right — and even with their own lawyers, each side is locked inside its own view.

My role is the outside seat: the one person in the room who is not invested in either version of events, who keeps it calm, and who finds the deal a courtroom isn’t built to give.

Why this works better than court

What a courtroom isn’t built to reach.

Solutions the law can’t reach

A court can only grant what the law allows — an order, an award, an injunction, a declaration — and it rules on who is right. Dispute resolution isn’t bound to that menu: a payment plan, an apology, a revised deal, a clean exit, an arrangement no judge could order. The better question isn’t who is right; it’s what actually works here.

The relationship, intact

Co-owners, family, partners, neighbours who still have to deal with each other afterward. A ruling names a winner; resolving it together lets both sides move on.

The real reason, not just who’s liable

Court asks what happened and who pays. Dispute resolution gets at what is underneath: the deadline someone could not meet, the partner who felt cut out, the money that has to come from somewhere. Fix that and the legal question usually stops mattering.

Control over how it ends

In court, a stranger you never met dictates the outcome. Here nothing is imposed — you decide, and you sign only what you agree to.

What resolution looks like

In a few weeks, it’s simply done.

The matter is closed, privately. You have an agreement you helped write, not a ruling handed down to you. If the relationship mattered, it is intact. And you are back to your business, your family, your life — instead of feeding a file for the next year or two.

What we resolve

One specialty. Three people on the other side.

Every file here is real estate. What changes is who is standing on the other side of it — and that changes almost everything about how it gets resolved.

The other side of a deal
A transaction that did not close, or is about to not close. Deposits, failed closings, assignments, extensions, something discovered after the fact, a commercial lease that has gone wrong. There is usually a real clock on these, and both sides can feel it.
A co-owner or a partner
You own it together and you no longer agree what happens to it. Siblings, friends who bought in a better year, partners and shareholders whose asset is the building. One of you wants out, one wants to keep it, and neither wants to hand the decision to a court.
A separation or an estate
The property is the hard part of something larger. A separation where the house is the biggest thing either of you owns, or an estate where several people inherited one building. You each keep your own lawyer, and some of this belongs with them before it belongs with me.

The bigger pictureIn every one of these, the legal question is only part of it. Money, timing, control, pride, relationships, and what happens tomorrow matter just as much — and the workable deal is almost always built out of those, not out of who was right.

How it works

Structured, written, and done in weeks.

1
The Framework

The dispute, in writing

Both sides receive the same document: what the contract says, how the law reads in both directions, what a court could actually do, and what the fight would cost. It collapses “my side is obviously right” for everyone at once.

2
The private read

Where you really stand

Each side gets a candid, confidential assessment — your strengths, your exposure, and a realistic settlement range. Framed as probability, never as a promise, and never shared with the other party.

3
The session

A signed agreement

A focused online session where each side is heard, ending in a written memorandum that becomes a binding deal once you put it in final form. You keep control the whole way. Nothing is decided for you.

The line I hold

The Framework is an impartial read of the contract and the law that applies, given to both sides identically. It is not legal advice, and it never interprets the law in favour of one party — each of you is free to have your own lawyer advise you, and the decision is always yours. My only job is to make sure neither side negotiates as though the answer were already obvious.

Taran Aujla
Taran Aujla
Problem-solver first. Mediation is how I do it.
  • Mediator · Ontario
  • REALTOR® · Ontario
  • Registered · Real Estate Council of Ontario
Background
  • Former lawyer · 10 years
  • Complex business & real estate matters
Education
  • LL.L / LL.B · University of Ottawa, National Program
  • Real Estate Salesperson Program · Humber · 2024
Languages
  • English · French · Punjabi
Who runs the room

For close to a decade I practised business and real estate law in Ontario, and worked through several hundred transactions and complex matters. But the disputes worth solving were never only about the law. They were about people, money, timing, pride, and what happens next.

So that is how I work a problem. I look at all of it: the legal exposure, the numbers, what the property is actually worth, who needs what by when, and what each side can realistically live with. Then I keep asking questions until the answer is obvious to both of you rather than just to me.

I am not there to re-argue the law. Your lawyer does that, and should. What I bring is the transaction itself. Having sat on the legal side of several hundred of these, and selling property now, I know where a deal actually breaks, what each step costs, and how long it really takes. Most of these are solvable long before anyone files anything, and for a fraction of what the fight would cost.

Your lawyer and your agent stay exactly where they are. I work alongside them, not instead of them, and I am happy to deal with them directly if that is easier for you. Nothing I do replaces independent advice, and I tell every party to get it.

I am neutral by design. I act for neither side, I give no legal advice, and the decision is always yours.

The impartiality rule

I never take the listing, the sale, or any brokerage work arising from a dispute I mediate. Neutrality you can check, not just a claim.

Strategic Advisory

Everyone sees their corner. Someone has to see all of it.

I work privately with executives, business owners, principals and individuals carrying a decision where the moving parts do not fit inside any one professional’s lane.

Your lawyer is right about the legal exposure. Your accountant is right about the numbers. But the money, the timing, the people, the incentives and what tomorrow looks like all sit in one situation, and somebody has to hold the whole board. We take it apart, find what actually matters, pressure-test every path, and decide what happens next. Here I’m your advisor, not the neutral — one side, one point of view, yours.

Explore strategic advisory →
Fees

A fixed price, known before we begin.

Framework Report
from$900
The written analysis, joint and private, with no session. The cheapest way to learn whether your position is worth fighting for.
Half day
from$2,200
Both reports plus a focused session — five hours of preparation and session time combined. Suited to a single clear question, like a deposit or a failed closing.
Full day
from$3,800
Both reports plus a full session — eight hours of preparation and session time combined. For co-ownership, estate, and multi-issue disputes with more to work through.

Starting points — the fixed price for your matter is set and agreed before we begin, and scales with its complexity and the amount at stake. Split between the parties unless agreed otherwise. A deposit is payable when the date is booked, and is credited against the fee.

If a session is cancelled inside 48 hours the full fee applies, and between two and five days, half. The time is reserved for you and cannot be given to anyone else at short notice.

I take a limited number of matters each quarter.

Common questions

The one everyone asks first.

“Why not just file a claim first? Won’t they only take me seriously once I sue?”
It’s the most common instinct — and usually the most expensive one. Filing is the slowest, costliest way to be taken seriously: it hardens both sides, brings in lawyers whose training is to fight, and starts a two-to-four-year clock. And here is the part few people realize — most claims settle anyway, just years and tens of thousands of dollars later. A mediation invitation, coming from a neutral, signals something different: that you are serious about resolving this, not prolonging it. It is one fixed fee, split between you, against the tens of thousands a side that litigation runs. And if it doesn’t work the courthouse is exactly where you left it — you can always file after, and agreeing to mediate stops your limitation clock while it runs (see below). You can rarely un-file gracefully. Both sides usually wait for the other to blink; the smarter move is to be the one who opens the door.
Am I running out of time? What about the limitation period?
In Ontario the general rule is two years. Section 4 of the Limitations Act, 2002 says a proceeding cannot be started “after the second anniversary of the day on which the claim was discovered,” and section 5 sets out when a claim counts as discovered: broadly, when you first knew, or a reasonable person in your position ought to have known, that the loss happened, that it was caused by the other side, and that going to court would be an appropriate way to deal with it. There is also a fifteen-year outer limit under section 15.

Here is the part that matters for choosing mediation. Under section 11, where both sides have agreed to have an independent third party resolve the claim or assist them in resolving it, the limitation periods in sections 4 and 15 do not run from the date of that agreement until the claim is resolved, the process is terminated, or a party withdraws. In plain terms: signing an agreement to mediate pauses the clock rather than burning it. You are not trading away your right to go to court by trying to settle first.

Two practical points. The pause covers the claim the parties agreed to work on, not everything outstanding between them — and scope is precisely what gets fought about afterwards. In Sandro Steel Fabrication Ltd. v. Chiesa, 2013 ONCA 434, the Court of Appeal confirmed that an agreement to mediate does not have to name the specific claim to engage section 11, and that the agreement can even be inferred from how the parties behaved. Helpful law — but those parties still spent time in court arguing about what they had agreed to mediate. That is avoidable. A signed mediation agreement that lists every issue in play settles both the date and the scope before anyone has to litigate them, which is why I put one in place before we begin.

Two honest cautions. Not every claim runs on the two-year clock — some real property claims, for example, are governed by different legislation. And whether your particular clock has started, or how much of it is left, is a legal question about your specific facts. I am a neutral and I do not give either side legal advice, so if timing is anywhere near tight I would strongly recommend having a lawyer confirm your dates rather than relying on anything here. If a deadline is genuinely close, the usual answer is to protect the claim and mediate anyway — the two are not alternatives.
What is mediation, exactly?
Mediation is a private, voluntary process where an impartial third party — the mediator — helps two sides in a dispute reach their own resolution, instead of a judge imposing one. Nothing is decided for you, and nothing is binding until you both agree. It is faster, cheaper, and more private than court: most matters resolve in weeks, on a fixed fee, and what is said stays confidential. In real estate, business, and family disputes, the mediator looks beyond the legal positions to what actually needs resolving — the money, the timing, and the relationships.
What if the other side refuses to come?
It only takes one side to open the door. A reasonable invitation to mediate is hard to refuse — when a judge fixes costs at the end of a case, rule 57.01(1) lets the court weigh any written offer to settle and “the conduct of any party that tended to shorten or to lengthen unnecessarily the duration of the proceeding” — which can include having refused to talk. And because the invitation comes from a neutral rather than from your opponent, it is far easier for the other side to accept without feeling they have conceded anything.
Is anything decided, or binding?
No. Mediation is entirely non-binding — nothing is imposed on either side, and I decide nothing. You reach a resolution only if you both agree to it, and any agreement is written up as a memorandum of understanding, which you can then put into binding form — through your own lawyers if you have them, or between yourselves if you do not. Until you sign, you keep every legal right you walked in with.
Do we need our own lawyers?
No. You are entitled to mediate without one, and plenty of people do — two business partners who understand their own arrangement often do not need anyone else in the room. What I do is recommend independent legal advice, because I am neutral: I act for neither side and I give no legal advice, so there is nobody in the room whose job is to tell you what a deal is worth to you. If you already have a lawyer, keep them. If you do not, the sensible middle is a single review before you sign anything binding. Either way the choice is yours, and it does not change how I run the mediation.
Is it confidential?
Largely, and I would rather be precise than reassuring. The process is private and without prejudice: under rule 24.1.14 of Ontario’s Rules of Civil Procedure, all communications at a mediation session, and the mediator’s notes and records, are deemed to be without prejudice settlement discussions. Nothing said in the room is evidence against you on the merits of the case. That is what makes it safe to speak plainly.

What it does not mean is that mediation is sealed off completely. Without prejudice is not the same as inadmissible. Three things can still surface later. First, costs: at the end of a case a judge fixing costs may consider any written offer to settle and “the conduct of any party that tended to shorten or to lengthen unnecessarily the duration of the proceeding” (rule 57.01(1)) — which can include how a party showed up at mediation and what it put on the table. Second, enforcement: a settlement you sign is a binding contract, and a party who later refuses to honour it can be held to it. Third, professional conduct: a lawyer’s behaviour in the room remains subject to the Rules of Professional Conduct.

Those are the defaults. The written agreement to mediate can narrow the first of them, and I raise it with both sides before we start rather than leaving anyone to discover it afterwards.
Start here

Bring the dispute. Leave with an agreement.

On timing

Ontario’s general limitation period is two years from the day a claim is discovered. Agreeing to have a neutral help resolve it suspends that clock under section 11 of the Limitations Act, 2002, so starting here does not cost you time. If your deadline may be close, tell me in the form — and this is one point where I would recommend a lawyer check your dates, since I act for neither side and cannot advise you on them.

TodayYou send your inquiry
Within 48 hoursI reply personally; with your go-ahead, the other side is invited
5 business daysThe Framework, in hand
2–3 weeksYour session
Dispute Situation You Send

Step 1 of 4

Who is on the other side?

Pick whichever is closest. Nothing is sent until the last step.