Renovation · Ontario

The renovation went wrong, and now nobody will move.

The work is unfinished or unacceptable, money has been paid, more is being demanded, and the trust is gone. These are among the most expensive disputes to litigate relative to the amount actually at stake.

A renovation that went wrong

Tell me what happened. If a lien deadline is in play, ask your own lawyer this week.

Private, and nothing is sent to anyone else without your go-ahead. Prefer to talk first? Call or text (365) 645-7332.

Thank you. Your inquiry is in.

I reply personally, and in confidence, within one business day. If it is time-sensitive, call (365) 645-7332.

Why these go so badly

A renovation dispute has a particular shape. The amount in dispute is often $40,000 to $300,000 — big enough to matter enormously to a homeowner, and small enough that litigating it can consume most of it.

It is the classic case where both parties end up worse off than almost any settlement they could have reached in month one.

The two roads

Litigated

Expert reports on both sides about the quality of the work, which cost real money before anyone has argued anything.

A year or more, with the house in the state it is in now.

Legal costs that can approach or exceed the amount in dispute.

And a judgment against a contractor who may not be collectable.

Mediated

A single jointly instructed assessment of what is actually done and what it would cost to finish, instead of two competing ones.

The money split against that number rather than against two opinions.

Frequently a completion arrangement — the work finished on defined terms with a holdback, which is what the homeowner actually wants.

Weeks. Fixed fee, split.

One thing to check today

Before anything else

If a construction lien may be involved, there are deadlines, and they are short. That is a question for a lawyer and it is worth asking this week rather than next.

Mediating does not remove those deadlines. Ask your own counsel what applies to you, and then decide how you want to resolve the substance.

Start privately.

Tell me what happened. If mediation suits it, I approach the other side myself — neutrally, and never without your go-ahead.

Start privately →

Or call or text (365) 645-7332. Nothing is sent to anyone else without your go-ahead.